Book #69 The A.B.C. Murders

The A.B.C. Murders by Agatha Christie
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

I first read The A.B.C. Murders back in the 70s. Last week I watched the BBC TV adaptation starring John Malkovich as Hercule Poirot - Poirot, but not as you know him! I had to read the book again just to confirm what a travesty the BBC airing was! The book for the most part is narrated by Poirot's old friend Captain Arthur Hastings, O.B.E. who has returned in June 1935 from his ranch in South America to see to various affairs at home. He looks up his old friend who is now retired but still practiced his profession on occasion. The BBC for reasons best known to themselves completely omit Hastings from the cast list! DCI Japp figures prominently in Poirot's previous investigations and he plays his usual rôle in the book - BBC have him retired and bump him off with a heart attack in the first scene... And Malkovich? Well - he is not David Suchet!

Despite all of this, reading the book again so soon after the TV show was very rewarding. It did not spoil my enjoyment in the slightest. I won't go into the details of the plot as I am sure most of you will be familiar with it. The book really is Agatha Christie at her best. And those little grey cells? Don't get a mention on the BBC!





View all my reviews

Book #73 The Mysterious Affair at Styles

The Mysterious Affair at Styles by Agatha Christie
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

If I have read The Mysterious Affair at Styles before I really don't recall the occasion. The Christie book that introduces the famous Belgian detective Hercule Poirot was first published in January 1921 and in the original manuscript, Poirot gives his explanation of the crime from the witness box during the trial. The publisher, John Lane, opined that this courtroom scene was not convincing and he requested that she amend it. Christie agreed to a rewrite. The explanation of the crime remains the same where Poirot unveils the murderer in the drawing room of Styles in the kind of dénouement that would be replicated in many later books. This edition of The Mysterious Affair at Styles is the first to restore Christie's original unpublished courtroom ending to her book. Was John Lane right in insisting on a rewrite? Well, the reader has the opportunity to decide as both versions of chapter 12 "The Last Link" are included in this new edition. A unique edition and a definite keeper for me.

TMAAS is a very well contrived, skilful tale - full of surprises as Hercule Poirot uses his little grey cells and powers of detection to find out who poisoned the wealthy Emily Inglethorp. How did the murderer penetrate and escape from her locked bedroom? And the amiable Captain Hastings is on the scene to help (or one might muse - hinder!).

If you haven't read TMAAS and you enjoy a classic whodunit, treat yourself to a copy of this unique edition. It is worth adding that I bought my copy from Amazon USA as it is in America that this edition is published by William Morrow.

View all my reviews